Add a goal setting specific to protein and total calories, fat and carbs set as loose targets

Calories = Set total based on goal (loss, gain, maintenance)
Protein = Firm target (ie 1g/pound ideal weight)
Fat & Carbs = each can have a loose target but they share the total remaining calories after subtracting the protein goal, on a shared dynamic slider. Over on carbs? Fat automatically adjusts down. Over on fat, carbs automatically adjust down. As food is logged during the day the slider automatically adjusts fat/carbs grams up/down while staying within the calorie goal.

Over/under for the day is based on calories not grams with visual if targets were met (like yellow for under, green for met, red for over), separating protein over/under based on firm target from the shared fat/carbs over/under.

Comments

  • It's unlikely to work, to set calories you need accurate "expenditure" estimate.

    Basically, TDEE = total calories you burn in a day.

    To figure out this, you need to use adaptive tdee technique.

    Also, A 2020 systematic review by Fuller et al. found that consumer wearables often perform poorly at estimating energy expenditure, even when they measure steps and heart rate reasonably well. Across brands like Apple, Garmin, Polar, and Withings, calorie burn estimates frequently showed substantial error, often in the 15–40% range and sometimes exceeding 50%. Wearables can still be useful for tracking trends, but not for precise calorie calculations.

    https://forums.cronometer.com/discussion/7331/tdee-calculators-are-scam-and-do-not-work-dont-bother-with-them-heres-far-more-accurate-method#latest

  • Thanks! What I meant though was like this, for example:

    User sets their daily calorie goal = 1950

    User sets their non-negotiable protein goal = 160g (min) aka 640 calories

    Remaining calories = 1310 (for fat and carb intake)

    Now, say the desired carb intake is 40% of total calories (780 calories or 195g), that leaves 530 for fat (59g). However, from day to day, the actual intake varies. On a higher fat day, carbs would dynamically decrease when fat consumption is more than 530 calories.

    This would simplify tracking for those of us who prioritize protein and are less concerned about how fat/carbs fill in the remaining calories.

  • AlexS
    edited November 11

    The way you described it is how it works in the MacroFactor ($80 a year) or MacroCodex (free app); you can pair it with Cronometer. This way, you can track in Cronometer.

    They call it adaptive target calories and macros.