Cooked vs Uncooked
Curious if a food does not say cooked or uncooked (chicken thighs) if I should assume its cooked?
I cooked some boneless skinless chicken thighs and there are a lot of different options. Not sure why these are so different? I guess its not a huge deal but just want to make sure I am utilizing these items correctly
The two options I was looking at is
Chicken Thigh, Skin Removed - 42g Protein
Chicken Thigh, Skinless, Grilled - 37g protein
Answers
-
If you're weighing your chicken after cooking, use a cooked chicken thigh entry. If you're weighing it before cooking, use a raw chicken thigh entry. Don't mix raw weights with cooked nutritional values.
Also, 42g versus 37g per 100g is a fairly meaningful difference (about 13.5%)
Also, such most of the accuracy a person will gain here will be lost to poor calorie burn estimation, see this:
https://forums.cronometer.com/discussion/7351/secret-of-achieving-very-record-high-accuracy-with-cronometer-like-a-super-nerd/p1?new=1 -
Right I understand that if I am weighing after cooking to used the cooked entry. The question stems from if it does not specify cooked or raw, what should I assume?
Also not sure why the two entries I shared are so different than.
-
I am curious, too @murraych. I have always typed in "cooked" or "raw" -- but you are right--when it is not stated what should we assume?
In the early years of Cronometer, someone from the company side would have just jumped in answered/clarified. I see that doesnt happen any more like it used to. I searched on "what if an entry doesnt say cooked or raw?" just to see if an answer (none immediately) but appears to be a long-running question.
Since no one has answered, can you just default to adding "cooked" or "raw"? I assume that the default is raw but I didnt build the database
-
The difference is mostly water. Cooking drives about a quarter of the weight out of the chicken, so the same piece reads as more protein per 100 g once it's cooked. That's why the two entries look so far apart — they're probably measuring the same meat at different stages, or in different serving sizes.
If an entry doesn't say cooked or raw, check the calories per 100 g. Raw chicken thigh is around 120 calories per 100 g; cooked is closer to 180. The calorie number tells you which one it is.
The simplest fix is to match the entry to how you weighed it. Weigh it raw, log the raw entry. Weigh it cooked, log the cooked entry. Never mix the two — that's where the error creeps in.
-
You assume raw, unless the entry explicitly says cooked, roasted, grilled, boiled, etc.
Also, you can look at the "database name" then figure out if it generally lists cooked or raw.
many calorie tracker have agents who you can ask.
