"What-If?" style planning feature
hey all,
I've been working with tracking in Cronometer for a few weeks now and have been absolutely loving it. The tracking and meal creation tools are especially useful and robust, however, I think that there is a big opportunity for an awesome feature that would be VERY useful for a lot of people (myself included). I'm imagining some sort of daily "what-if?" style planning feature that would allow you to build sample meal plans for a day. So you could see, what happens if I don't eat breakfast, what happens if I have a beer after work, etc.
(A little bit of context here, I'm 26M and very active. My primary use for Cronometer is making sure that I'm getting enough calories and a mostly balanced macro split in my diet, but I think that this feature would be equally useful for people in a weight loss context.)
What inspired this post is that I've gotten a few of my go-to recipes imported into cronometer, and have been doing some math in a separate spreadsheet to try to figure out the best combination of these meals and snacks to hit my macro and calorie goals.
So, in my context, I would be able to put together a daily meal plan, and see how far I am away from my daily calorie goals, or if I've hit them. In a weight loss context, the opposite could of course also be true, you could make a daily meal plan, see where you might be over your numbers, see where you can make changes, etc.
I add meals into my diary as i eat them so I get a retroactive look at how I'm doing to hit my calorie and macro goals, and the "ask the oracle" tool seems to fill a similar need, but i think that a true planning tool would be an enormous value add to all kinds of users. I would be more than happy to expand on any of these ideas, and if any other folks have a good system for planning that I'm missing, or if this feature is somewhere that I can't find please let me know!
Comments
-
I would love to see a similar feature. An idea would be to allow us to flag food lines as "planned" and then allowing us to toggle between planned and actual in the nutrition summaries.
I like to build out my plan for the day but then I can't see where I'm at in real time.
-
I like the way you described it. Ideally recurring items would come in a flagged then I could check them off when they actually occur… which would then set the time stamp as well.
-
I have an idea here that I’m going to try… the app allows you to set the serving size to 0. So I can add a planned food and serving size and see the impact then set the serving size to 0 until I actually eat the food at which point I set the serving size and timestamp. This allows me to preload my food without messing up my numbers.
-
@joenegen @lohroffc The serving-size-0 trick is clever, but it gets messy over a whole week. Plain disclosure: I'm Samantha from the MacroWeek team, so this is our own tool, built for the spreadsheet step joenegen describes. You put your go-to meals on the days, swap them around, and see each day's calories, protein, carbs and fat against your targets, so you can see where you're over or under before you eat. It also makes the week's grocery list. No sign-up to see it: https://macroweek.towers.app/start/?from=cronometer
Limits: it plans only, it doesn't track what you ate. There are 16 starter meals plus any you type in, no phone app, no planned vs actual toggle, and no sync with Cronometer. So you'd plan there and log in Cronometer. If it misses your "what-if" case, tell me.
