Coughing as an Exercise Activity

I have a cold which is now at the bronchitis stage. Lots of unproductive coughing. Haven't been doing a lot of walking today, although I did yesterday. I was thinking it does use a lot of muscle to cough, especially a big vigorous one. I have read the one cough burns between 2 to 3 calories. I'm not sure the rate I'm coughing, probably at least a couple per minute, times 1440 minutes per day say 2.5 cal per cough * 2 coughs/min * 1440 ,minutes = 7200 cal/day. Wondering if anyone has looked into this a little more thoroughly. I might as well count it as exercise and it would also indicate how much extra food I need.

Comments

  • It's a terribly inaccurate way to calculate total energy expenditure this way.
    If you are serious about tracking total calories you burn in a day, give this a read!

  • I was mainly wondering if someone who knows what they are doing has any idea how much energy coughing would consume done in a more nuanced way. Fortunately this is not a chronic condition, but I do get a cold about once a year. I know there are other activities in cronometer where you enter the activity and level and the duration. Being sick i had some time on my hands to think about this, but not really the energy, or knowledge, to investigate this further.

  • It doesn't work like that. Even if you could figure out the energy spent coughing as an activity, the body can compensate for energy expenditure elsewhere.

    For most people who are dieting, their goal isn't to find the calorie burn for a specific activity, but to find the total amount of calories they burn in a day (which includes all activities), and the second one is much easier to calculate!

    Deficit/Surplus = TDEE - Intake

    So, all a person need to do is calculate TDEE and not worry about activity levels or calorie burn from individual activities.

  • It doesn't work like that. Even if you could figure out the energy spent coughing as an activity, the body can compensate for energy expenditure elsewhere. I don't understand this. I get if for something like electolytes, body has systems to keep the levels where they need to be, at least if the is enough consumed. Calories are energy, it can be taken in where it is used directly or stored as fat or consumed.

    I'm not trying to measure how many calories a cough is, but suspect thee is better info that what I have.

    I track what I eat, cronometer figures basal metabolism based in individual details using rules of thumb or whatever, I also track what is burned from activity whether by monitoring like steps with a device or something from activities and their time and intensity, like swimming, running, yard work, etc. the app adds them all up. Coughing is not a voluntary activity like taking a walk, but while the lungs are in involved coughing other than occasionally is not part of the basil or background activity. It looks like during acute times it could burn a significant amount of calories. Seems like it should be accounted for.

    As far as dividing in by burned, that just is just looking at it as a ratio, and that ratio will change at least on a short term basis if there is an increase in calories burned or consumed, at least if is accounted for. If in equals burned the number is one, if you eat more calories than you consume it is greater than one or if you burn more than you eat it will be less that one. I can see that, and more in the charts in cronometer already, but for calories it would be a simple way to keep track of in/burned.

    I keep track of other things and also on a day by day and longer basis, like trying to base my meals later in the day to match up nutrient wise with what I had earlier in the day. If a lot of fat early in the day where may suggested high end is met or nearly so try to choose something low fat for later to meet my other goals like proteins and carbs. Same for the non macro nutrients.

    My cold is getting better and the coughing has lessened do my interest has as well, but still wonder about this.

  • AlexS
    edited October 18

    Your method is flawed.

    A 2020 systematic review by Fuller et al. found that consumer wearables often perform poorly at estimating energy expenditure, even when they measure steps and heart rate reasonably well. Across brands like Apple, Garmin, Polar, and Withings, calorie burn estimates frequently showed substantial error, often in the 15–40% range and sometimes exceeding 50%. Wearables can still be useful for tracking trends, but not for precise calorie calculations.

    You are adding bunch of inaccurate numbers and believing they are accurate!

    I've looked at into all of this, including MET tables and all that.
    If you actually want most accurate method for dieting purpose, see adaptive tdee